Moody’s Investors Service casts critical eye on Fidelity
December 9th, 2007The future of Fidelity Investments, the Boston mutual fund giant, is clouded because of the concentration of power in the hands of its 77-year-old chairman, Edward (Ned) Johnson 3rd, Moodys Investors Service warned.
Moodys said it had growing concerns about the control wielded by Johnson at Fidelitys parent company, FMR. Its board includes Johnson family members and longtime associates and no independent directors “whose presence would create some confidence that there is some check on Mr. Johnson,” Moodys wrote in a report Wednesday.
The New York rating agency left unchanged its rating on the debt and credit outlook of Fidelity, in which the founding Johnson family holds a 49 percent stake, though it noted that FMRs total debt had soared.
Moodys also cited increased competition in Fidelitys core mutual funds business and the low profit margins at its other businesses as issues facing one of the states major employers.
The comments give an institutional voice to questions others have raised lately about performance and governance practices at Fidelity, which Johnson has put into makeover mode this year following a period of lagging returns at its mutual funds.
Among other things this year, Johnson has replaced his No. 2 executive, reorganized its business units, and, most recently, transformed the structure of the Fidelity parent, FMR.
But the reclusive Johnson has yet to explain his thinking publicly or discuss questions like whether his 45-year-old daughter, Abigail Johnson, will follow him as leader of the company.
Moodys wrote that Fidelitys “lack of clarity” on the successor issue creates uncertainty that could hurt its efforts to attract new executives.
Moodys cited “significant market speculation” about whether Abigail Johnson “is the best possible person” to take over when her father steps down.
“These factors, to varying degrees, hamper FMRs ability to defend its position in an increasingly dynamic and complex industry,” Moodys wrote.
Johnson was not available to be interviewed Wednesday, said a Fidelity spokeswoman, Anne Crowley. He has declined numerous interview requests in the past.
“We disagree strongly with the majority of the views expressed in the report,” Crowley said. “The fact of the matter is that Mr. Johnson and the Fidelity board have succeeded over the years in creating one of the most successful and fast-growing financial services companies in the world.”
The company has no immediate plans to sell additional debt, she said.

Posted in 