Venture capital and private equity compete for Asian deals
February 27th, 2008REDWOOD CITY, California: Venture investors and private equity firms are competing for the same deals in China and India, looking to avoid risk by funding companies that are selling products rather than untested ideas.
“The lines between venture capital and private equity are blurring” in China and India, said Navin Chaddha, the managing director of Mayfield Fund, which has investments in both countries.
“Most of the money is moving toward growth companies and larger-ticket size deals,” Chadda said at a conference in Redwood City on Tuesday.
Although there is no dearth of entrepreneurial talent in these countries, which collectively secured more than $320 billion in investments last year according to Dow Jones data, U.S. investors prefer to put their money in tested companies, panelists at the conference said.
The unfamiliar regulatory terrain, sketchy protection for intellectual property, especially in China, and stories of fly-by-night operators have scared venture firms away from funding ideas that are still on paper.
“There was a certain euphoric rush into China,” said Nicholas Unkovic, a partner at the global law firm Squire, Sanders Dempsey.
He said some initial investments in China may already have petered out because investors misjudged their local partners or the quality of talent.
“A lot of money is going to be made in China and a whole lot of money is going to be lost in China, but investors are going to get more sophisticated about this,” Unkovic said during the panel discussion, part of a two-day conference organized by Dow Jones.
Stella Xi Jin, a partner at IDG Ventures who divides her time between Silicon Valley and China, said that only a small amount of the money raised by venture capitalists goes into early-stage deals because investors want to avoid these pitfalls.
“More than half the dollars would go to growth funds,” she said.
Growth funds typically invest in middle- to late-stage companies that already have a marketable product or service and may even be profitable.
Even when funds claim to finance companies in their initial phase, the definition of “early-stage” is different from what the term means in the context of a U.S. investment.
A typical “Series A” round for a U.S. start-up would be in the range of $2 million to $12 million, but first-round funding for Chinese and Indian companies could be as high as $50 million, the panelists said.
Since fund-raising through the venture capital and private equity routes is still new in China and India, many companies seeking a first round of funding are already up and running and require more cash than a U.S.-style garage venture, they said.
Rafiq Dossani, who runs Stanford Universitys South Asia initiative, said that regulatory costs in India also keep away smaller venture investors - those with between $1 million and $2 million to invest.
But it has become easier to invest, especially in the technology sector, as the Indian government cuts away some of the bureaucratic red tape, he said.

Posted in 