Riding out the storm with Deutsche BГrse
April 20th, 2008FRANKFURT: A steep slide this year in the shares of the stock exchange operator Deutsche Bцrse, because of fears of lower trading volumes and tougher competition, looks out of step with the fundamentals of the company.
Nothing seemed to go wrong last year for the company as revenue grew strongly thanks to growth in trading volumes, and as profit increased from some adroit moves on property holdings and taxation.
The Deutsche Bцrse share price also almost doubled, helped on the way by a stock buyback.
With the rapid increase in its market capitalization, the exchange shares were admitted to the Dow Jones EuroStoxx 50 league of European blue chips, triggering a 27 percent rise in the shares between mid-October and the end of 2007.
By comparison, rivals like CME Group in the United States, the Spanish exchange operator BME and the London Stock Exchange saw share price gains of 34.5 percent, 48 percent and 51 percent, respectively, in 2007.
An index of world exchanges rose 70 percent, driven both by a rise in trading volumes and by sector consolidation. Deutsche Bцrses $2.8 billion bid for the International Securities Exchange, for instance, came with a nearly 50 percent premium.
Deutsche Bцrse, which runs the derivatives platform Eurex and the settlement and custody house Clearstream, bought ISE, the U.S. options exchange, in 2007, creating the first trans-Atlantic franchise in the rapidly growing derivatives trading segment.
“In 2007, everything was positive and still early in the first quarter this year only positive news was recognized in the market,” Martin Peter, an analyst at LBBW, said. But “the performance on the upside was overdone, now there is exaggeration also on the downside,” he added.
Thus far in 2008, Deutsche Bцrse shares have lost more than one-third of their value, underperforming other exchanges and the DJ EuroStoxx 50 index. The shares have fallen more than 15 percent in April, the latest drop driven by Morgan Stanley, which slashed its price target to \115, or $181, from \155, or $244.
“The price drop is absolutely not justified and has been triggered by negative sentiment due to feared trading volume declines,” said Felix Braune, an analyst at Crйdit Agricole Cheuvreux.
Morgan Stanley justified the reduction in the price target with a 7 percent cut in its 2008 earnings estimates, and a 9 percent cut in 2009, pinning those to “lower cash, derivative and settlement growth assumptions.”
Morgan Stanley and other analysts pointed out that stock exchange traded cash equity volumes account for less than one-fifth of Bцrse group revenue, with Clearstream making up some 40 percent and Eurex around 30 percent.
“The market has focused excessively on the volumes in early April which have been seasonally weak,” Credit Suisse said in a research note dated April 17. “The key for Deutsche Bцrse is its derivatives business,” Credit Suisse said. It reiterated its estimate of 21 percent derivatives volume and revenue growth in 2008 compared with revenue 2 or 3 percent higher at Xetra and Clearstream.
Deutsche Bцrse is to report its first-quarter results on May 6.
The rival electronic trading platform Chi-X on April 7 reported a 256 percent rise in first-quarter trading volumes, prompting speculation that it and other upstarts, notably the Project Turquoise due to begin later this year, will grab market share from established exchanges.
“Its highly questionable if these players can gain market share from Bцrse, so far they have not succeeded in doing so but rather taken on volumes” from the over-the-counter market,” said Braune at Cheuvreux.
Market consensus puts the Bцrse 2009 price-to-earnings ratio at 14.3 compared to an average 16.4 for global exchanges. The discount, now 210 basis points, has widened by 50 basis points in the past month as Bцrse shares have fallen.
The Credit Suisse analyst Rupak Ghose considers the shares “extremely attractive.” Morgan Stanley, whose bear scenario for Bцrse comes with a price target of \70 versus \160 in a bull scenario, reiterated its “overweight” rating on the stock.

Posted in 